Why I Think Goodwill Is Overpriced

A thrift store 

Today, I strolled into Goodwill with a specific mission: to hunt for some second-hand designer accessories and wallets. I had my fingers crossed for a hidden gem, but what I discovered was a mixed bag, to say the least. I spotted a cute authentic Vera Wang handbag and an authentic Nautica handbag that caught my eye. But here’s the catch—I had to pass on both. 

Why? Because I can afford to buy those brands new. Honestly, if I wanted a Vera Wang or Nautica handbag, I could just visit their official websites and get a fresh piece. I’m not in the market for a hand-me-down when the brand-new options are within my reach. Plus, let’s be real: my current handbag works just fine.

Another reason I find myself shying away from carrying bags into stores lately stems from some unpleasant realities. As a Black woman, I’ve become acutely aware of how people can perceive me, especially in retail environments. There’s a certain tension in the air; I worry that some might assume I’m going to steal something from the store simply because of the color of my skin. So, I’ve started leaving my purse behind while I shop.

On my in-person mission today, all I needed was a flashy wallet to spice things up—but alas, there was no luck on that front either. 

Now let’s talk about the dresses. Goodwill’s pricing for dresses is around $7.99. Seriously? Who in their right mind would pay that for a no-name dress? If it’s not a designer label, it just doesn’t add up to me. When stores like Rainbow are selling brand new dresses with the tags on them for $3, $5, and $10, why would anyone opt for a pre-owned no name item from Goodwill that doesn't have a designer label on it? 

A clothing store that I used to work for in 2006, nearly two decades ago, way before I started releasing music and books 

And don’t get me started on Citi Trends, which often has those same nameless dresses in their clearance racks for under $8. It feels like getting the short end of the stick. As a former employee of Citi Trends, I saw many authentic designer brands and nameless brands for a low price. 

At the end of the day, I appreciate thrift stores and what they stand for—finding value and sustainability in second-hand goods. However, I can’t help but feel that sometimes these places miss the mark when it comes to pricing. If you ask me, I believe there are way better deals to be had elsewhere. 

###